Skip to content
Corporate Home  |  Tyco Electronics Segment Indicator Electronic Components  |  Segments  |  Who We Are
Elo TouchSystems Home
Sign in to Elo e-Services
Visit www.tycoelectronics.com Elo TouchSystems
Email Email  

Compare All Elo Touch Technologies

Compare All Resistive Touch Technologies (4-, 5-, 6-, 7-, 8-wire variations)

Print version of this page (55K PDF)

Key
Best in category

BestBest
Some advantage

Better
Neutral

Neutral
Perhaps not acceptable

Worse
Not possible, worst in category

WorstWorst

  APR AT4
4-wire

resistive
AccuTouch
5-wire

resistive
IntelliTouch
surface wave
SecureTouch
surface wave
iTouch
surface wave
Surface
capacitive
Projected
capacitive *
CarrollTouch
infrared
Performance:                  
Speed
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Worse
BestBest
Sensitivity
Better
Neutral
Neutral
Better
Better
BestBest
BestBest
Neutral
BestBest
Resolution
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Neutral
BestBest
Accuracy
BestBest
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Worse
Worse
BestBest
Calibration Stability
BestBest
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Worse
Neutral
BestBest
Drag
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Better
BestBest
Neutral
BestBest
Z-axis
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
Double Touch 1
BestBest
Worse
Worse
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Worse
Neutral
Neutral
Parallax (lack of)
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest 2
Neutral
Worse
Worse 3
  APR AT4
4-wire

resistive
AccuTouch
5-wire

resistive
IntelliTouch
surface wave
SecureTouch
surface wave
iTouch
surface wave
Surface
capacitive
Projected
capacitive *
CarrollTouch
infrared
Input Flexibility:                  
Glove
BestBest 4
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
WorstWorst
BestBest
BestBest 4
Finger
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Fingernail
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
Worse
Better
Credit Card
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
Better
Pen
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
Better
Signature Capture
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
Handwriting Recognition
Better
Worse
Worse
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
  APR AT4
4-wire

resistive
AccuTouch
5-wire

resistive
IntelliTouch
surface wave
SecureTouch
surface wave
iTouch
surface wave
Surface
capacitive
Projected
capacitive *
CarrollTouch
infrared
Optics:                  
Light Transmission
BestBest
Worse
Worse
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest 5
Worse
Neutral
BestBest
Reflection (lack of)
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest 5
WorstWorst
Neutral
BestBest
Clarity
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
Color Purity
BestBest
BestBest
Worse
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
  APR AT4
4-wire

resistive
AccuTouch
5-wire

resistive
IntelliTouch
surface wave
SecureTouch
surface wave
iTouch
surface wave
Surface
capacitive
Projected
capacitive *
CarrollTouch
infrared
Mechanical:                  
Small Sizes (<10")
BestBest
BestBest
Worse
Worse
Worse
WorstWorst
Neutral
Worse
Worse
Large Sizes (>19")
BestBest
WorstWorst
Worse
BestBest
WorstWorst
Neutral
Worse 6
Neutral
BestBest
Curved CRTs
Neutral
WorstWorst
Neutral
Neutral
WorstWorst
BestBest
Neutral
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
Ease of Integration
Better
BestBest
BestBest
Worse
Worse
Worse
Better
Worse
Neutral
Sealability
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Worse 7
Worse 7
Worse 7
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
IP65; NEMA4
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
  APR AT4
4-wire

resistive
AccuTouch
5-wire

resistive
IntelliTouch
surface wave
SecureTouch
surface wave
iTouch
surface wave
Surface
capacitive
Projected
capacitive *
CarrollTouch
infrared
Electrical:                  
Controller Chip Available
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
Neutral
BestBest
Low Power; Battery Operation
TBD
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Operation with Poor Ground
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
Neutral
ESD
BestBest
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Worse
Neutral
BestBest
EMI; RFI
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Worse
WorstWorst
BestBest
  APR AT4
4-wire

resistive
AccuTouch
5-wire

resistive
IntelliTouch
surface wave
SecureTouch
surface wave
iTouch
surface wave
Surface
capacitive
Projected
capacitive *
CarrollTouch
infrared
Environmental:                  
Temperature
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Humidity
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
Shock; Vibration
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
Altitude
Better
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
In-vehicle
TBD
Better
Better
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
Chemical Resistance
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
WorstWorst
BestBest
BestBest
Scratch Resistance
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Neutral
BestBest 8
BestBest 8
Breakage Resistance
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
Neutral
BestBest 8
BestBest 8
Safe Break Pattern
Neutral
Better
Better
Neutral
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
Dust; Dirt
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
Worse
Liquids
Better
BestBest
BestBest
Worse 9
Worse 9
Worse 9
BestBest
BestBest
Worse
Rain
Better
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
Neutral
BestBest
Worse
Snow
Neutral
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
Worse
BestBest
Worse
Ice
Neutral
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
WorstWorst
Worse
BestBest
Worse
Ambient; UV  Light
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Fly on Screen
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
WorstWorst
Non-Glass Surface Possible 12
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
Works Through Other Materials
Better
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
Neutral
Durability; Wear
BestBest
Worse
Better
BestBest
BestBest
BestBest
Better
BestBest
BestBest
EMI; RFI
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Worse
Worse
BestBest
Surrounding Metal
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Worse
Worse
Neutral
  APR AT4
4-wire

resistive
AccuTouch
5-wire

resistive
IntelliTouch
surface wave
SecureTouch
surface wave
iTouch
surface wave
Surface
capacitive
Projected
capacitive *
CarrollTouch
infrared
Reliability; Warranty Length
BestBest
WorstWorst
Neutral
BestBest
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
BestBest
Lowest Cost
Neutral
BestBest
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Better
Neutral
Worse
Worse

Notes

* This technology is currently unavailable in the United States
Worse = incorrect (averaged) coordinate reported; BestBest = simultaneous touches rejected, nearly simultaneous touches reported accurately
2 Touch is closest to image as there is no overlay
3 Touch activates just before actual contact (1mm)
4 Only technology recommended for metal gloves
5 The utmost possible as there is no overlay
6 For LCDs only; plasma is not possible, due to EMI
7 Special sealing materials required (Elo touchmonitors are watertight sealed)
8 Assuming proper materials used
9 Although splashing liquids are OK, extended rain and humidity exposure can lead to internal condensation
10 Works with stationary water drops; excessive or moving water must be wiped away
11 Polyester coversheet may yellow after years of exposure
12 Required for food processing and some in-vehicle applications

No guarantee of acceptability of the technology to the application is implied by this quick reference table